480-626-2282
FHA or Conventional: Which Loan Fits Your Arizona Home Purchase?

Neither loan is better for everyone when you are buying a home in Arizona. An FHA loan is insured by the Federal Housing Administration and follows HUD rules, while the conventional loans discussed here follow Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac guidelines; the fit depends on your credit, down payment, debts and how long you plan to keep the home.

By Greg Gale, licensed mortgage loan originator, NMLS #193428, NOVA Home Loans
Published November 6, 2026 (America/Phoenix)

For a buyer in Scottsdale or the Phoenix metro, the useful question is what each choice means for your own cash, monthly payment and plans. Compare the purchase price, down payment, monthly insurance and the time you expect to keep each loan.

How do FHA and conventional loans compare?

HUD’s FHA insurance and Fannie Mae’s conventional mortgage guidelines are different frameworks. Fannie Mae describes purchasing conventional fixed-rate mortgages in its Selling Guide, dated December 14, 2022. HUD’s Single Family Housing Policy Handbook, revised August 12, 2026, describes FHA requirements. Lenders review the complete application, and their standards may be stricter.

Talk through your Arizona mortgage options
Call The Gale Team: (480) 626-2282

Program rules as published by HUD (Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1, revised August 12, 2026) and Fannie Mae, checked November 1, 2026. These are agency rules, not terms offered by The Gale Team or NOVA Home Loans.

FactorFHAConventional
Down paymentHUD rule: At least 3.5% required investment under HUD rules; score affects maximum financing.Fannie Mae rule: As little as 3% for a qualifying Fannie Mae option, with conditions.
CreditHUD has score tiers for maximum financing.Fannie Mae’s score rules depend on underwriting method.
Debt-to-incomeManual: 31% housing and 43% total debt base ratios; higher ratios require specified conditions.Fannie Mae manual: 36% total debt, up to 45% with conditions; Desktop Underwriter: 50% maximum.
InsuranceHUD rule: 1.75% upfront; for terms over 15 years and base loans up to $726,200, annual MIP is 0.50% or 0.55% depending on loan-to-value.Private mortgage insurance may apply and can end under applicable rules.
OccupancyAt least one borrower must occupy the home as a principal residence within 60 days of signing the security instrument and intend to stay at least one year.Occupancy rules depend on the loan and intended use.
Loan limitHUD 2026 Maricopa County one-unit limit: $557,750.FHFA 2026 Maricopa County one-unit conforming limit: $832,750.

Nothing in the table is a loan offer; it is not a loan quote. For a one-unit Maricopa County home in 2026, HUD’s FHA loan limit is $557,750 and FHFA’s conforming limit is $832,750.

Meet your Arizona mortgage team
Meet The Gale Team

Down payment and credit: compare the conditions

As of HUD’s August 2026 handbook revision, FHA’s minimum required investment is at least 3.5% of adjusted value. A decision credit score of 580 or higher is eligible for maximum financing under HUD’s score rules. Under HUD’s August 2026 handbook revision, a score from 500 through 579 is limited to 90% loan-to-value, generally meaning at least 10% down; a score below 500 is ineligible for FHA insurance. These are agency thresholds, not a promise of approval. See the HUD handbook.

Fannie Mae’s 97% loan-to-value options, checked November 1, 2026, include a 3% down path for certain one-unit principal residences with fixed-rate financing and automated underwriting. The standard option requires at least one first-time buyer. Its other option has an income limit.

Conventional does not have one universal credit cutoff. Fannie Mae’s credit score guide, dated November 4, 2026, says its Desktop Underwriter casefiles do not require a minimum score; the system assesses risk factors. Manually underwritten fixed-rate loans have a 620 minimum, and adjustable-rate loans have a 640 minimum. Lenders can apply higher standards. Learn more about credit scores for buying a house in Arizona.

How debts enter the comparison

Debt-to-income ratio, or DTI, compares monthly debt payments with gross monthly income. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, in guidance reviewed August 28, 2023, describes it as one way lenders measure the ability to repay. It is useful to consider the proposed housing payment alongside the obligations you already carry.

Talk through your Arizona mortgage options
Call The Gale Team: (480) 626-2282

Under HUD’s handbook, revised August 12, 2026, the manual underwriting base ratios are 31% for housing and 43% for total debt. Borrowers with scores of at least 580 can qualify for higher ratios with specified compensating factors; automated FHA underwriting is evaluated differently. Fannie Mae also distinguishes manual underwriting from Desktop Underwriter in its DTI guide, dated April 2, 2025. Fannie Mae allows a 36% total DTI for manual underwriting, up to 45% with qualifying credit and reserves, and a maximum 50% for Desktop Underwriter.

A payment that fits an underwriting calculation still deserves a household budget check. Think about the room you want for other expenses and savings. For manual underwriting under the same HUD handbook, FHA starts at 31% housing and 43% total debt and can reach 40% and 50% with a score of at least 580 and specified compensating factors. Fannie Mae’s guide dated April 2, 2025 allows 36% total DTI for manual underwriting, up to 45% with qualifying credit and reserves. Desktop Underwriter has a maximum of 50%, while automated FHA files are evaluated differently.

Meet your Arizona mortgage team
Meet The Gale Team

Mortgage insurance: how long could it last?

Talk through your Arizona mortgage options
Call The Gale Team: (480) 626-2282

FHA mortgage insurance includes an upfront premium and an annual premium. HUD’s premium table, effective March 20, 2023, in the handbook revised in August 2026, lists an upfront premium of 1.75% of the base loan amount, which may be financed or paid in cash. For terms over 15 years and base loans at or below $726,200, annual MIP is 0.50% at up to 95% initial loan-to-value and 0.55% above 95%. For the purchase loans in that table, an initial loan-to-value ratio of 90% or less means annual MIP for 11 years; above 90%, it runs for the mortgage term.

Conventional private mortgage insurance, or PMI, has different cancellation rules. For covered loans, the CFPB explains in guidance reviewed August 28, 2026, that you may request cancellation when the balance is scheduled to reach 80% of the original value, or earlier through extra payments, subject to conditions. A written request, good payment history, evidence that value has not declined below the original value and certification of no junior liens are among the conditions.

For covered loans, the same CFPB guidance says the servicer generally must terminate PMI automatically at the scheduled 78% point if payments are current. A final termination rule applies after the loan’s midpoint. FHA insurance and lender-paid mortgage insurance follow different rules. HUD’s premium table, effective March 20, 2023, also lists 1.75% upfront, and annual MIP lasts 11 years when the initial loan-to-value is 90% or less. The amount of mortgage insurance for any specific loan appears in the Loan Estimate the borrower receives, which also shows the APR and the monthly payment.

Meet your Arizona mortgage team
Meet The Gale Team

How do loan limits and property rules affect an Arizona purchase?

For 2026, HUD’s FHA mortgage limits lookup lists a $557,750 FHA forward loan limit for a one-family home in Maricopa County. The limit applies to the loan amount, not the home’s purchase price. The FHFA 2026 conforming limit for one unit in Maricopa County is $832,750, also on the loan amount. As of November 5, 2026, neither HUD nor FHFA has posted 2027 limits. HUD’s 2026 FHA limits apply to case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2026, under HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-23, dated December 11, 2025, so a loan whose FHA case number is assigned in 2027 may face a different limit. The applicable limit varies by year, county and number of units.

The home itself matters as well. Under HUD’s handbook, revised August 12, 2026, FHA minimum property requirements address the safety, soundness and security of insured homes; minimum property standards address those concerns for new construction. When an appraiser observes noncompliance, HUD requires the appraiser to note necessary repairs and an estimated cost to cure. Required repairs can affect the financing of a home that needs work.

The property review depends on the loan and the home. If you are married, ask how ownership and signatures apply to your transaction under Arizona law, checked November 1, 2026.

Start your mortgage application
Apply with The Gale Team

How can you choose between FHA and conventional?

Start with credit and the cash you want to put down. HUD’s handbook, revised August 12, 2026, sets a score threshold of 580 for maximum FHA financing and limits a score of 500 through 579 to 90% loan-to-value. But a small down payment alone does not settle the question: some conventional options also permit a small down payment, subject to their own conditions. The CFPB’s loan comparison, updated February 18, 2026, says conventional loans typically cost less than FHA loans but can be harder to get, and describes FHA as a low down payment option available to those with lower credit scores. Those are general tendencies, not outcomes for any one buyer.

Compare a conventional scenario alongside FHA when reviewing stronger credit or a larger down payment. Consider the initial cash required, the full proposed monthly payment and how the mortgage insurance changes over time. A buyer expecting to keep the loan for a long time may weigh insurance duration differently from someone whose plans are shorter. Neither a future move nor a refinance is assured.

Under HUD Handbook 4000.1, FHA requires at least one borrower to occupy the home as a principal residence within 60 days of signing the security instrument and intend to stay at least one year, so if you are buying a second home or rental, ask about other options. Next, bring the property and loan amount into the conversation. A home in Scottsdale, Paradise Valley or elsewhere in the Phoenix metro needs to fit the applicable loan and property rules. The applicable loan and property rules shape the comparison.

For more detail, see our guides to conventional loans in Arizona and mortgages for first-time Arizona buyers.

Talk through your Arizona mortgage options
Call The Gale Team: (480) 626-2282
Meet your Arizona mortgage team
Meet The Gale Team

Frequently Asked Questions

Is FHA always cheaper than a conventional loan?

No. The costs depend on the individual loan, down payment and insurance, as well as how long you keep it. Ask for a side-by-side comparison for your circumstances.

Can a conventional loan have a smaller down payment than FHA?

Yes. Fannie Mae describes a conventional option with a smaller down payment than HUD’s minimum investment for FHA, as checked November 1, 2026; the comparison table gives the dated rules. Each has conditions and neither promises approval. These are agency program rules, not terms offered by The Gale Team.

Does FHA mortgage insurance go away?

It depends on the starting loan-to-value ratio. HUD’s premium table, effective March 20, 2023, ends annual MIP on FHA purchase loans after a set period at a lower starting ratio and keeps it for the mortgage term at a higher one; the mortgage insurance section gives the dated figures. Ask how the table applies to your loan.

Does the Arizona loan limit mean the home price must be below it?

No. The limit applies to the loan amount, not the purchase price. Your down payment and other applicable rules still matter.

Should I decide before I find a property?

It helps to discuss your credit, funds, debts and target loan amount early. A particular property and its condition can also affect the comparison, so revisit the choice when you have a home in mind.

About Greg Gale

Greg Gale is a licensed mortgage loan originator with NOVA Home Loans, NMLS #193428. For a conversation about your Arizona home purchase, call The Gale Team at (480) 626-2282.

Start your mortgage application
Apply with The Gale Team

Sources

Sources checked November 1, 2026. Agency guidelines can change.

Equal Housing Lender. NMLS #193428. Loans subject to credit approval.
NOVA Financial & Investment Corporation, DBA NOVA Home Loans, NMLS 3087, BK 0902429
The Gale Team at NOVA Home Loans · 7975 N. Hayden Rd #C-200, Scottsdale, AZ 85258 · (480) 626-2282